AI Doomsday Prophecies
Joseph Olive, CFP®
AI Doomsday Prophecies
At a recent Rotary meeting, a member joked we will all soon die from AI. He was citing a recent thread on X that has been hard to miss.
Recently, a 27-year-old researcher named Jacob Coxon resigned from Anthropic. He announced it on X. The people constructing these models, he wrote, “earnestly believe that it could kill us all by the end of the decade.” They were “gambling with our lives.”
The post was seen more than 150 million times. A colleague still inside the company, alignment researcher Evan Hubinger, did not walk it back. “We really do earnestly believe AI could kill all humans,” he replied, putting his own estimate above 10 percent this decade. Other engineers at Anthropic and Google DeepMind said versions of the same thing.
The joke in Cuero, TX landed because the thread did. A resignation in San Francisco becomes lunch conversation in DeWitt County in Texas by the end of the week.
Then Washington noticed. Sen. Bernie Sanders said Coxon was right and promised a ban on superintelligence. Other members of Congress called for hearings and kill switches. Within days, a lab debate was on cable news.
The timing made the volume louder. This week Netflix is releasing The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist, in which an expectant father asks whether AI will save civilization or end it. A resignation on X, a political pile-on, and a documentary in the same window. That is how modern alarm travels. It does not prove the question is fake. It does mean we should take notice.
I have written before that AI is a powerful tool and a poor substitute for judgment. Nothing in the last week has changed that view.
Elon Musk has warned about AI for more than a decade. He has compared building it to summoning a demon and said advanced systems may be riskier than nuclear weapons. In July, he told The Economist that humans may no longer be “in charge” within ten years, and that he still puts the chance of catastrophe around 10 to 20 percent. Then came the less-quoted line. Even if there were a stop button, “we probably shouldn’t press it, because the most likely outcome is incredible abundance for all.”
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has been the clearest voice on the other side. He called the claim that AI will end humanity “complete nonsense,” and listed predictions that missed: radiologists gone in five years, half of entry-level jobs gone in months. Whistleblowing about real problems is healthy. Treating a guess about 2030 as settled science is not.
The sharper flaw in a unilateral slowdown is strategic. China is not waiting for an essay from San Francisco. Beijing treats AI as a national project: military power, surveillance, manufacturing, and a chance to leapfrog U.S. productivity. If American labs tap the brakes and Chinese labs do not, we do not buy safety. We buy a transfer of advantage. That shows up in the economy first and in national security second. A pause that only the open societies honor is not prudence, but rather, a one-sided arms control treaty with no other signer.
We have seen this pattern. After Hiroshima, people wondered whether the next war would be the last. Nuclear weapons remain dangerous, but they have not yet ended civilization. In 1968, Paul Ehrlich’s The Population Bomb told readers that hundreds of millions would starve in the 1970s. They did not. Y2K was supposed to freeze the modern world at midnight. It became a punchline. During COVID-19, the disease was real and deadly. Some of the most cinematic forecasts of collapse were not. Climate change is a genuine long-term problem. Some of the most specific near-term extinction slogans attached to it were not.
The sequence is familiar. A real technology or real threat arrives. People closest to it are sincerely frightened. Media and politics compress that fear into a deadline. The deadline slips.
Consider what both sides are saying. Do not outsource your judgment to a viral thread or a politician. Review information independently. Do not regulate in a panic that protects incumbents, and do not slow the free world while a rival communist state runs full speed.
Joe Olive, CFP®, MPS, is a 10-year Air Force veteran who works as a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® with Sather Financial Group, a fee-only strategic planning and investment management firm. He holds a master’s degree from Columbia University.
